Quick Guide to Public-Private Partnerships (P3s) in Puerto Rico – Legal Framework and Opportunities

10 min read

A quick guide to Public-Private Partnerships (P3s) in Puerto Rico. Explore the legal framework, tax benefits, and opportunities for private entities to partner with the government successfully.

Introduction

Public-Private Partnerships (P3s) have long been a cornerstone of Puerto Rico’s strategy for modernizing infrastructure and enhancing public services through effective collaboration with the private sector. With the PNP (Partido Nuevo Progresista) now leading the government, spearheaded by Governor Jenniffer González Colón, the island is poised for a new wave of P3 projects. González Colón was Speaker of the House when Act 29-2009, the foundational P3 legislation, was enacted, and Thomas Rivera Schatz, who served as Senate President during that pivotal time, holds the same leadership position today. Historically, the PNP has been the driving force behind major infrastructure projects and is the only political party to actively promote P3s under the existing legal framework. Their current platform reaffirms this commitment, emphasizing the use of P3s for infrastructure development. Learn more about their infrastructure priorities here.

What Are Public-Private Partnerships?

A Public-Private Partnership (P3) is a structured contractual collaboration between a government entity and a private partner. Through this partnership, the private entity assumes responsibilities traditionally managed by the public sector, which may include financing, constructing, operating, or maintaining infrastructure or public services. The primary objectives of a P3 are to improve service quality, optimize costs, and effectively allocate risks between public and private partners.

In Puerto Rico, P3s have been pivotal in addressing critical infrastructure and public service needs. Notable successes include the Luis Muñoz Marín International Airport, the first airport in the United States to be privatized under a P3 framework. This groundbreaking project demonstrated the potential of P3s to deliver innovative, high-quality solutions while setting a benchmark for future initiatives in sectors like transportation, energy, and water management.

By leveraging the expertise and efficiency of the private sector, P3s offer a sustainable model for modernizing public infrastructure and enhancing services to meet the demands of a growing population.


The Legal Framework: Act 29-2009

Puerto Rico’s Public-Private Partnership Act (Act 29-2009) provides the legal foundation for developing, evaluating, and implementing P3 projects. Designed to address critical infrastructure and public service needs, this law outlines a structured process that ensures transparency, accountability, and alignment with public interest. Oversight and regulation are managed by the Public-Private Partnerships Authority (P3A), tasked with ensuring that all P3 projects meet economic goals and deliver value to the public.

Key Provisions of Act 29-2009

  • Project Identification: Both public agencies and private entities can propose P3 projects aimed at addressing infrastructure gaps or enhancing public services. Proposals must align with the government’s strategic priorities and policy objectives.

  • Evaluation and Selection: Each proposed project undergoes rigorous feasibility studies to assess its technical, financial, and social viability. This ensures that only projects with clear public benefits and sustainable frameworks move forward.

  • Transparency and Accountability: To foster public trust, the law mandates competitive bidding processes and robust public oversight. This ensures fairness in project selection and promotes responsible stewardship of public resources.

Act 1-2017 Amendment: Enabling Unsolicited Proposals

In 2017, Act 1-2017 amended Act 29-2009 to incorporate provisions for unsolicited proposals. This change allows private entities to take the initiative in proposing innovative projects, even without a prior government request. By expanding the scope of project development, this amendment encourages creativity and private-sector investment while maintaining the same rigorous evaluation and oversight standards.


Stages of a Public-Private Partnership (P3) in Puerto Rico

1. Identifying Opportunities

The P3 process begins with identifying critical public infrastructure or service needs, such as modernizing energy systems, improving transportation networks, or upgrading public facilities. These opportunities must align with Puerto Rico’s strategic development goals and government priorities. Potential projects can be initiated by public agencies looking to address specific challenges or by private entities proposing innovative solutions.

2. Desirability and Convenience Study

Before any formal proposals are requested or accepted, the Desirability and Convenience Study is conducted. This essential analysis evaluates whether pursuing the project as a P3 aligns with public interest and government policy. The study examines factors such as technical and financial feasibility, the social and economic benefits of the project, risk allocation between public and private partners, and long-term sustainability. Only projects deemed desirable and convenient proceed to the next stage. To maintain transparency, the study’s findings are made publicly available.

3. Proposal Submission and Qualification

Once a project passes the desirability study, the proposal stage begins. For solicited projects, the government issues a Request for Qualifications (RFQ) to identify private entities capable of executing the project. Only those entities that demonstrate the required technical expertise, financial stability, and operational capacity are invited to respond to a Request for Proposals (RFP). This stage requires detailed submissions, including technical solutions, financial strategies, and risk allocation plans.

For unsolicited proposals, private entities may submit project ideas directly to the Puerto Rico Public-Private Partnerships Authority (P3A). These proposals undergo an initial review to ensure alignment with public priorities. Depending on the project, the P3A may require the proposer and potential competitors to undergo a qualification process to validate their capabilities.

4. Evaluation and Approval

Once submitted, proposals undergo rigorous evaluation by the P3A. The authority assesses the project’s alignment with public needs, technical and financial feasibility, sustainability, and overall public benefit. Particular attention is given to value for money and effective risk management. Based on the evaluation, the P3A may approve the project to advance to competitive bidding or, in specific cases, enter direct negotiations with the original proposer.

5. Contract Negotiation

After approval, the public and private entities negotiate the terms of the partnership. This stage formalizes roles and responsibilities, financial arrangements such as cost-sharing and revenue models, and performance metrics to measure success. Risk management mechanisms and dispute resolution processes are also included in the agreement. The aim is to establish a balanced contract that safeguards public interests while providing clear incentives for the private partner to deliver high-quality results.

6. Implementation and Oversight

Once the partnership agreement is finalized, the private partner assumes responsibility for executing the project. This includes financing, construction, and operational phases. Throughout implementation, the P3A and other relevant government agencies monitor compliance with contractual terms, ensuring that performance standards are met. Regular audits and reviews are conducted to maintain accountability and transparency.


Advantages of Puerto Rico’s P3 Framework

Puerto Rico’s Public-Private Partnership (P3) framework, governed by Act 29-2009, offers private entities a structured and transparent pathway to collaborate with the government on transformative projects. Below are the key advantages participants can leverage.

1. Tax Benefits

One of the most attractive features for private entities engaging in P3 projects is the availability of tax incentives. Depending on the project’s nature and scope, private partners may qualify for exemptions from property taxes, excise taxes, and sales and use taxes. These financial incentives, combined with revenue-sharing arrangements often included in P3 contracts, enhance the profitability and viability of participating in Puerto Rico’s P3 initiatives.

2. Confidentiality Protections

The P3 framework ensures robust confidentiality measures to safeguard proprietary information. From trade secrets to technical designs and financial models, all sensitive data shared during the proposal, evaluation, and negotiation phases is protected. This assurance allows private entities to confidently propose innovative solutions without fear of unauthorized disclosure, creating a secure environment for collaboration.

3. Collaborative Evaluation Through Desirability and Convenience Studies

The Desirability and Convenience Study is a cornerstone of Puerto Rico’s P3 process, evaluating whether a proposed project serves the public interest and aligns with government policy. This phase is highly collaborative, allowing private entities to contribute technical and financial insights while refining their proposals to align with public goals. The study also assesses socio-economic benefits, risk-sharing mechanisms, and long-term sustainability, ensuring a comprehensive evaluation that maximizes public impact while mitigating risks for private partners.

4. Transparent and Predictable Processes

Puerto Rico’s P3 framework is built on principles of transparency and accountability. All stages of the P3 process, from Requests for Qualifications (RFQs) to competitive bidding, are conducted under strict regulatory guidelines. Public notices and consultation periods ensure stakeholders and the community are informed and involved, creating an equitable environment for private participants. Additionally, clear timelines and well-defined regulatory procedures reduce uncertainty, making the process predictable and efficient.

5. Long-Term Sustainability and Stability

P3 agreements in Puerto Rico emphasize sustainability, often including provisions for ongoing maintenance, operational responsibilities, and performance metrics. These elements ensure that private entities benefit from predictable, stable opportunities over the long term while maintaining the quality of infrastructure and public services. This long-term perspective incentivizes private partners to deliver high-quality outcomes and provides steady returns on investment.

6. Acceptance of Unsolicited Proposals

Puerto Rico’s P3 framework, amended by Act 1-2017, allows private entities to submit unsolicited proposals directly to the Public-Private Partnerships Authority (P3A). This provision offers a unique opportunity for private sector innovators to introduce projects that address public needs without waiting for a formal government request.


Challenges to Consider

Despite its advantages, participating in a P3 project comes with challenges:

  • Regulatory Complexity: Navigating Act 29-2009 and its regulations is just one part of the compliance process. Businesses must also consider other applicable local and federal laws, which can vary depending on the industry involved. For example, environmental regulations, labor laws, and industry-specific standards may come into play. Expert legal guidance is essential to ensure full compliance with all relevant frameworks, mitigating risks and avoiding potential delays

  • Community Engagement: Building trust and gaining community support are critical for the success of any P3 project. Clear communication about the project’s public benefits, transparency in the decision-making process, and addressing community concerns proactively can help foster acceptance and collaboration.

  • Risk Allocation: Effective risk allocation is crucial for the success of any P3 project. Contracts must clearly delineate the roles, responsibilities, and liabilities of both public and private partners. This includes specifying who will bear financial, operational, and regulatory risks. A well-structured agreement minimizes misunderstandings, prevents disputes, and ensures that each party is equipped to manage their assigned risks effectively.

  • Planning for the Future: Successful P3 agreements require long-term planning to address potential changes and challenges over the lifespan of the project. Contracts should include provisions for adaptability, such as mechanisms for renegotiation, updates to regulatory compliance, and contingencies for unforeseen events. Future-proofing the partnership ensures sustainability, allowing both parties to achieve their objectives while maintaining high-quality service delivery over time.


Conclusion: A Pathway to Collaboration

Public-Private Partnerships provide a transformative approach to addressing Puerto Rico’s infrastructure and service challenges. By combining government oversight with private sector innovation, P3s enable the development of sustainable, impactful projects that benefit the island’s economy and its residents.

Puerto Rico’s P3 framework presents an exceptional opportunity for private entities to contribute to the island’s growth while benefiting from a robust and transparent legal structure. With the PNP’s renewed focus on infrastructure development under Governor Jenniffer González Colón and Senate President Thomas Rivera Schatz, the conditions are ripe for transformative public-private collaborations. Businesses can expect a supportive regulatory environment, bolstered by the leadership’s commitment to leveraging P3s for economic and social progress.

As Puerto Rico positions itself for a new era of infrastructure modernization, private entities have the chance to play a pivotal role in shaping the island’s future. With confidentiality protections, tax incentives, and collaborative evaluation processes at the heart of the P3 framework, now is the time to explore the possibilities of partnering with the government.

Looking to start a Public-Private Partnership (P3) in Puerto Rico? Contact MZLS today. As experienced P3 lawyers, having been involved in almost every public private partnership agreement to date, we specialize in navigating Puerto Rico’s Public-Private Partnership framework, from proposal submission and compliance to contract negotiation and long-term success. Let us help you maximize the potential of your P3 project.